
Platform Choice
Community platform selection
Choose a community platform by checking discussion fit, customer access, moderation, data export and the work your team can support.
Start with the conversations members need, the access rules the business must enforce and the work the team can sustain. A polished trial space fails if staff cannot handle reports, customers reach the wrong areas or the organisation cannot retrieve its records. Discourse, Circle and Mighty Networks illustrate the plan limits and prices to compare.
Write the requirements before comparing products
Describe three likely member tasks: finding an answer to a recurring question, comparing experience with peers, and raising a sensitive account problem in private support. For each, specify who may read, start, reply to and moderate the exchange. Decide whether an answer must remain findable and current.
Separate essential requirements from preferences. Treat access rules as essential where the business must restrict entry; assess visual themes as preferences.
| Decision area | Question to settle | Evidence to seek in a trial |
|---|---|---|
| Discussion | Must answers remain findable, or is timely exchange the main value? | Test a realistic question and how a newcomer finds it. |
| Access | Can the platform enforce the required entry rules? | Demonstrate the rules with relevant test accounts. |
| Moderation | Can the team review reports and follow up? | Demonstrate the reporting and follow-up controls. |
| Data | What must be retained or moved if the platform changes? | Check an available sample export and its limits. |
| Operations | Who maintains the space and its integrations? | Check plan terms, administrator controls and responsibilities. |
Match the product to the main exchange
Forum software such as Discourse can give a lasting question its own topic and category. Platforms such as Circle and Mighty Networks combine the community with courses, events and payments, which suits a membership business selling access. Check the chosen product rather than assuming its label determines what it can do.
Keep discussion format separate from hosting. Each of these products sells hosted plans with tiered limits; check the chosen plan rather than assuming it settles the format. If members need enduring answers and live conversation, choose a primary home and check how a useful exchange will be found later.
Check controls that protect the promise
Assess whether the platform can enforce the access rules the business needs, including a private route for sensitive account details where required. Check that the team can review reports and take follow-up action. On Circle, custom single sign-on (SSO) appears from the Scale plan.
For an organisation covered by the Australian Privacy Principles, administered by the Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC), APP 11 requires reasonable steps in the circumstances to protect personal information it holds.
For an APP entity, APP 11 also requires reasonable steps in the circumstances to destroy or de-identify personal information once it is no longer needed for a permitted purpose. The exceptions include information that is part of a Commonwealth record or must be retained under Australian law or a court or tribunal order. Include retention and deletion duties when assessing the platform's fit.
Prove the exit route
Confirm that the organisation can retrieve its data in a usable form. A member list, database backup and portable archive serve different purposes. Record whether the chosen plan provides an export route the team can use.
Discourse's hosted guide: an administrator can create a database-only backup that excludes uploads, while a full site backup including uploads is requested through the hosted guide's process. A backup that can restore a Discourse site does not establish that another product can import it.
Hosted infrastructure backups should not be confused with copies the organisation can access and manage. Discourse says its automated infrastructure backups are taken every 12 hours, but are not accessible on demand and are not a substitute for downloadable site-level backups. Record which backup tasks remain the organisation's responsibility.
Compare plan limits with expected use
Compare the plan's limits and included services against the team's expected use, and record the exact plan being assessed so a feature available only on a higher tier is not treated as confirmed.
Discourse's listed hosted tiers: the $100-per-month tier includes five staff seats and 20 GB of upload storage; the $500-per-month tier includes 15 staff seats and 100 GB. Both list unlimited members and categories, and 500,000 monthly page views; the listed monthly email limits are 100,000 and 300,000 respectively.
Circle lists Professional, which includes unlimited members, at $89 a month, Business at $199 and Scale at $419; Circle Plus is custom-priced. Its prices are in USD, based on annual billing, and exclude applicable taxes.
Mighty Networks lists its Launch plan at $79 a month, Scale at $179 and Growth at $354, with Mighty Pro on custom pricing for branded apps.
Discourse also states that its listed prices are in USD. Convert each price to Australian dollars at the time of the decision, add any tax that applies, and compare limits such as staff seats, storage, page views and email volume, rather than treating a monthly price alone as evidence that a plan suits the organisation.
Decide from a bounded trial
Give each candidate the same fictional, non-sensitive tasks: publish and find a question, and inspect an available export. Record whether the requirements identified earlier—including any required access and moderation controls—can be demonstrated. If a required export or control cannot be demonstrated, keep it open in the decision record.
Make the decision record specific enough to revisit, with these fields: product and plan, billing currency and AUD estimate, staff seats, storage and email limits checked, access and moderation controls demonstrated, export route tested, privacy duties covered and unresolved requirements with an owner. Before inviting customers, recheck any tier-dependent limits identified during the trial.
In this guide
- Comparing forum software with hosted group platformsCompare forum software and hosted groups by discussion structure, hosting responsibility, access controls and export limits.
- Checking data export before choosing a community platformCheck what a community platform actually exports, from threads and attachments to members and permissions, before relying on an exit plan.
- Assessing moderation tools during a platform trialUse realistic cases to check reporting, review, filtering, moderator permissions and recovery during a community platform trial.
- Choosing access controls for a customer-only communityDefine customer eligibility, visibility, permission changes and removal before choosing access controls for a private community.


