First members who can contribute: Look for people who ask good questions and answer from experience.; Include connectors and constructive challengers to diversify perspectives.; Check for missing customer journey stages and invite those views.
Image: Community Growth Desk

Onboarding

Part of Building an owned community around a business

Identifying the first members who can contribute

Find a useful mix of first community members by matching real member needs with questions, experience and willingness to contribute.

Seek first members who have a reason to use the community and a contribution they would be comfortable making. Include people who ask good questions, people who can answer from experience, and people who bring another relevant perspective. Aim for a small mix of real needs and capabilities, not a list of enthusiastic names.

Start with the exchange you want to make possible

Write down the first few kinds of conversation the community is meant to support. A customer forum might need a member willing to describe a setup problem and another who has worked through something similar. A professional group might need people from different roles who can compare how they make the same decision.

For each conversation, ask what a participant would need to know and why they might want to take part. A large audience or a senior title is not automatically useful if the person cannot speak to the shared task or does not want to participate.

Look for several ways to contribute

Use a working list rather than a public ranking:

Question askers
can describe a difficulty clearly and respond to follow-up questions.
Experienced peers
can explain what they tried, including limits or mistakes.
Connectors
can bring a relevant person or overlooked viewpoint into a discussion.
Constructive challengers
can question an assumption respectfully and surface a different approach.

One person may fit more than one role. Avoid choosing only customers who praise the business. Early conversations need room for uncertainty and honest problems, provided the team can respond appropriately.

Key Roles for Early Community Contributors

  1. Question askersDescribe difficulties clearly and engage with follow-up
  2. Experienced peersShare tried solutions, including limitations and mistakes
  3. ConnectorsBring in relevant people or overlooked viewpoints
  4. Constructive challengersRespectfully question assumptions and suggest alternatives

Check willingness without assigning a job

People who have already asked thoughtful questions, helped peers in an existing setting or volunteered for a relevant discussion may be worth approaching. That is a reason to ask, not permission to assume they will contribute. Tell each person what the community is for, why their perspective may help, what participation could involve and that declining is fine.

Offer a bounded first step, such as commenting on one proposed topic or sharing a question they wish others would answer. Do not promise visibility, status or influence the team has not agreed to provide. Ask before naming someone as a founding member or reusing their words in an invitation.

Notice whose experience is missing

Check the list against the intended audience. Does it include people at different stages, with different tasks or from different parts of the customer journey?

If everyone comes from the business’s closest contacts, the early conversation may reflect that group’s experience only. Record which perspectives remain absent and invite them through an appropriate route. Do not describe the initial members as representative of all customers.

Keep the first group manageable for the staff available to reply and moderate. Once people have participated, review what they found useful and which conversations still need another perspective. The first members should help the community begin learning, not become a permanent inner circle.

Balancing Perspective in Early Community Membership

Pros: Diverse experiences improve problem-solving
Includes users at different stages of the customer journey, roles, and needs
Cons: Risk of over-representing business contacts
Early conversations may reflect only close relationships, not broader user base

More from Onboarding